"The captivating and must-see life story of a New York hero you’ve never heard of...I also need to give a round of applause to Stephen Kaliski's direction. Kaliski has McPhee use every possible inch of that space, both matching and enhancing her physically dynamic performance." -Theatre is Easy, "BEST BET"
“Mary Shanley would be proud of the work Robert K. Benson has done in celebrating her story...an extraordinary performance by Rachel McPhee.” -Charged FM
"DEAD SHOT MARY is a special show. When you find an actress who can embody the real person, it’s as if you’ve struck gold. Rachel McPhee was that." -Theater in the Now
“A captivating performance by Rachel McPhee...All of the elements come together to paint a perfect portrait of this ordinary and yet remarkable woman.” -Talkin Broadway
“Rachel McPhee’s bravura performance as Mary is not to be missed.” -Theater Pizzazz